Wednesday, September 23, 2009

It just doesn't match up

What is true freedom? Can that have just one definition?

If you think about this in the view point of Banach's ideas then there is not one answer to this question. It's different for everyone. Therefore he is contradicting himself by telling us we are all free, How can he know what we are when "we cannot feel what is going on in any one else's mind." Unless Banach is some kind of supernatural force who can read minds then there is a major flaw in his arguement. What gives him the power decide how we see things and what we see or feel?

This is why I've decided that either Banach doesn't really believe what he's saying or too trapped in his own mind to realize that his ideology may only apply to himself.

This is why I find it hard to agree with Banach. Many points of his arguement make sense to me and I believe that he is on to something is is partially correct. However, his main point that we can understand each other or feel what others feel is simply incorrect. Again, if this is so then how does he know so much about what we feel and think or how we see things?

I think I've pointed out the biggest flaws of Banach's argument, now i would like to attempt to answer the question of our freedom and what freedom is.

There are two different types of freedom. Mental freedom and physical freedom. Mental freedom is something we all have that under no circumstance can be taken from us. We will always be allowed to believe what we want and in our minds we can picture whatever we wish. Our imagination and the thoughts inside our heads are limitless. I am allowed to think what i want "I have control over the content of my TV screen" says Banach reffering to his "mental TV screen." This is true nobody could ever enforce a law telling us what to believe in our own minds.

Physical freedom is a completely different story. This is limited. Not only do people have physical limits that do not allow them to fly, or morph in to other things but we also have limitations on things that are physically possible. Maybe I'm being confusing, but I'll try and explain. There are things that are physically possible that people are able to do but there are rules and laws restricitng us from doing these things or punishing us for these things. This many times is a good thing, it keeps people from harming other or doing things that are dangerous to others but it also restricts are freedom because you are not free to do these things. A very simple example is murder, you are not ALLOWED to kill someone else because you want to or for any reason, if you do this and get caught you will be punished. This is a good thing but it's also a restriction of freedom.

So when Banach says we have "absolute freedom" he's wrong. The word absolute implies that we have freedom in every sense of the word. Not true.

I think many people are confused by Banach's lecture and therefore simply agree. This is very understandable since many of his ideas make sense and are logical. I think looking deeper in to his argument you find that his ideas and theories are flawed.

Banach has some good ideas but overall I think his lecture says humans aren't smart enough or something enough to do something except for when it's in their own head but at the same time he doesn't apply the rule to himself. It just doesn't match. I think humans are capable of much more then Banach gives them credit for.

1 comment:

  1. OMAR,

    I liked how you did not simply just agree with Banach. Instead you took it to a deeper level. That shows you really put some thought into analyzing his ideas.
    You asked an overall question what is true freedom? Banach's main ideas are a contradiction from each other. If is not possible for a person is understand another persons feelings or thoughts, then it is not possible for Banach to understand our feelings or thoughts. Everyone has their own thoughts that are not limited with any boundaries.
    With rules and laws restricting us from doing certain things everything s more functional. As much as I like to believe I can do anything like fly or become invisible I know it just in my imagination. Because there will always be a physical limit.
    This is really well written. And all your ideas are easy to understand. it simplifies Banachs ideas, and brings up new points. What about the constant point Banach brings up about absolute individual? Do we have the free do really be an absolute individual?

    this has a great ending point too. You did done good! :P keep it up.
    ARDEN

    ReplyDelete