Tuesday, September 22, 2009

1st comments

Gavin,

This post basically summed up most of my thoughts. I agree with you 100 percent, I also believe humans do have the capacity to feel what others feel. Looking at this literally no one can ACTUALLY feel what someone else feels. However, I do think that people can feel the same things, im confusing myself here, I don't know if I'm making any sense but basically what I'm trying to say is that you can feel the same feelings as others.

People have so much in common and go through so many of the same things that I think it's inevitable that people will feel the same emotions as others. Now maybe it is your own emotion being revisited by someone else who is having that same emotion, but it is still the SAME emotion. I hope that makes sense.

Anyway I think the mentality that we are all alone is not a good one, I think it does more harm then good. Saying that we are all alone is saying that we can not relate or connect or come together as one, or it at least gives people the thought that it's not possible to come together with others. This si a twisted world we live in and with out a sense of unity and a group of people coming together things don't change. All change that has benefited the majority of people in the U.S has been caused by a large amount of people coming together and fighting for the same cause all having the same feelings or at least very similar feelings over the same thing. People are able to understand the ideology and feelings of other otherwise there would be no unity and I think we can agree that people do unite as it has happened in the past and is happening currently whether it be on a mass level or it be a smaller group of people, people do unite. Anyway, I feel like I'm repeating myself so I leave it at that hopefully I wasn't to confusing and it kind of made sense. Great post by the way. I look forward to more.

Arden,

That post was really good, especially the last paragraph. To me though the most interesting part of the post was when you ask if being individuals and only being able to truly understand ourselves makes us alone. I think that if you completely believe Banach's idea of individualism it does.

Banach's main point through most of the first part of the lecture is that we can really understand other only us and that we are all "stuck on our only islands of subjectivity." Now, this is true in many cases but I also believe that people can understand each other and have many of the same feelings. It is true that no two people are mentally identical but there are many things many people can share in common. Many times people go through the same expiriences and can relate and understand each other. I think that Banach is saying that we are alone and I think that is a potentially dangerous idea.

The idea that we are all alone and cannot connect and understand others is basically saying we can not come together and unite and I think that unity is what brings change when things go wrong. People do unite because of having the same issues and feeling the same way about certain things(not everyone feels the same way but many times some people do).

Anyway, those are just some of my thoughts of that idea. you had a really good post though and I look forward to reading future posts.

No comments:

Post a Comment