When Banach says that we are all absolute idividuals he is saying that we all understand things in different ways and its impossible to feel what someone else is feeling or understand them. He is saying that we are all stuck in our own little world and we can not truly relate to others. I disagree,, i think people can relate. It is true that everyone is different and unique but people deal with many of the same or at least similar situations. People go through and feel many feelings that are the same. This is a topic that can never really be proved but from personal expirience I can say that people can relate and understand eachother because i have done it before. When people say things and you know exactly what they mean while others don't I think thats an example of some people relating and understanding eachother. Another example is music, music is a form of self expression. Music that is full of feeling and personal expirience gives people a chance to connect to very personal expiriences that the artist goes though and some people who feel the same things the artist do feel like they know exactly what the artist means. That feeling of connection is something that many people feel and i thin that is a feeling of understanding and connection. So when banach says "Each of us is trapped within our own mind, unable to feel anything but our own feelings and expiriences." I believe he is wrong because people connect and understand eachother constantly and that is why some people are able to create groups and become tight friends.
However, I believe that in many cases people do not understand others, but this is not because we are not able to. I think many times the case is that people try to fit in and be something or someonne they are not, in this case i do believe it is impossible to understand someone else. When you are not truly yourself your lying and decieveing everyone around you and many times your lying to yourself. When someone really expresses who they are and is themselves people can connect becuse it is a true and real feelings tht is shared amongst many and not something that is copied from someone else. When you are yourself and share your own true feelings others who have been through similar situations as you or simply feel the same as you do can connect and its a real feeling of understanding and connection of real feelings.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
OMAR,
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed reading your post. I liked how you started with the other all idea and then got more in depth with your thoughts.
I like the points you made arguing Banachs points. That everyone experiences similar feelings. So we can relate to each other, which gives us some understanding. Although in some cases when people try to be something they are not it is impossible for someone to understand them, because their feelings are an act.
After reading your blog I thought about how often people use the phrase “ I understand” I couldn’t help but think about what was brought up in Andy’s class about really understanding something. How people will keep repeating themselves until they feel you understand. Weather that means you agree with them or tell them simply repeat what they say back to them. I think people just want to feel like they are understood. Understand what I’m saying?
Although I really liked how you used music as an example, To make this stronger you could go more in depth and talk about a personal story. it helped me get my point across when I was writing.
This defiantly got me thinking. It makes me wonder how much of an understanding we have of other people. And I beginning o think about the people I think understand me the best.
This was deep. You weren’t afraid to share your own ideas and agree and disagree with Banach. ☺
Arden