Arden,
Let me start by saying this was a really good post. I think in many ways you are right that we are all very much the same. It's pretty obvious if you look at our history blog you'll see all our videos are basically the same. Not much more needs to be said. The world around us affects us. I do believe we all have difference within ourselves I find it hard to believe there is someone out there who is exactly like me because after all there is more to us then what we decide to show people. I also find it hard to believe that no one has similarities and can relate to me or my feelings. For this reason I agree with you and disagree with Banach.
You make a good point saying that we act different around different people. This is very true. With your friends, teachers, parents whoever it may be we act different. It's very rare that we don't filter our sleves and hold back from saying certain things or doing certain things. I myself find it hard expressing who I really am with many of my friends. I think Banach says we can't relate to others because of this feeling of putting up a front and not being understood. Makes sense, until you find someone whoever it may be, your parents, a friend whoever that you are comfortable enough with to share your true self with and many times when you dot his other people open up and you have a genuine connection and a true understanding. Anyways I feel like I'm just rambling on, great post. Keep it up!
OMAR
Vin,
This was a really good post. You go in to a lot of depth on how our preception affects us a great deal. I completely agree. I think we can both agree that although Banach makes sense at some points he contradicts himself so much and he goes against almost everything. I personally think he full of shit. He can't possibly believe what he is saying. His whole arguement is about one persons incapability of understanding another yet he is telling us how we think and what we do and why we do things, those two just don't match up. It's just too full of holes for me too believe.
Anyway, you made a really good point I think you pointed out some really good points about how our perspective dictates our lives. Very true. You explained it very well. I look forward to more posts.
Omar
Tuesday, September 29, 2009
Wednesday, September 23, 2009
It just doesn't match up
What is true freedom? Can that have just one definition?
If you think about this in the view point of Banach's ideas then there is not one answer to this question. It's different for everyone. Therefore he is contradicting himself by telling us we are all free, How can he know what we are when "we cannot feel what is going on in any one else's mind." Unless Banach is some kind of supernatural force who can read minds then there is a major flaw in his arguement. What gives him the power decide how we see things and what we see or feel?
This is why I've decided that either Banach doesn't really believe what he's saying or too trapped in his own mind to realize that his ideology may only apply to himself.
This is why I find it hard to agree with Banach. Many points of his arguement make sense to me and I believe that he is on to something is is partially correct. However, his main point that we can understand each other or feel what others feel is simply incorrect. Again, if this is so then how does he know so much about what we feel and think or how we see things?
I think I've pointed out the biggest flaws of Banach's argument, now i would like to attempt to answer the question of our freedom and what freedom is.
There are two different types of freedom. Mental freedom and physical freedom. Mental freedom is something we all have that under no circumstance can be taken from us. We will always be allowed to believe what we want and in our minds we can picture whatever we wish. Our imagination and the thoughts inside our heads are limitless. I am allowed to think what i want "I have control over the content of my TV screen" says Banach reffering to his "mental TV screen." This is true nobody could ever enforce a law telling us what to believe in our own minds.
Physical freedom is a completely different story. This is limited. Not only do people have physical limits that do not allow them to fly, or morph in to other things but we also have limitations on things that are physically possible. Maybe I'm being confusing, but I'll try and explain. There are things that are physically possible that people are able to do but there are rules and laws restricitng us from doing these things or punishing us for these things. This many times is a good thing, it keeps people from harming other or doing things that are dangerous to others but it also restricts are freedom because you are not free to do these things. A very simple example is murder, you are not ALLOWED to kill someone else because you want to or for any reason, if you do this and get caught you will be punished. This is a good thing but it's also a restriction of freedom.
So when Banach says we have "absolute freedom" he's wrong. The word absolute implies that we have freedom in every sense of the word. Not true.
I think many people are confused by Banach's lecture and therefore simply agree. This is very understandable since many of his ideas make sense and are logical. I think looking deeper in to his argument you find that his ideas and theories are flawed.
Banach has some good ideas but overall I think his lecture says humans aren't smart enough or something enough to do something except for when it's in their own head but at the same time he doesn't apply the rule to himself. It just doesn't match. I think humans are capable of much more then Banach gives them credit for.
If you think about this in the view point of Banach's ideas then there is not one answer to this question. It's different for everyone. Therefore he is contradicting himself by telling us we are all free, How can he know what we are when "we cannot feel what is going on in any one else's mind." Unless Banach is some kind of supernatural force who can read minds then there is a major flaw in his arguement. What gives him the power decide how we see things and what we see or feel?
This is why I've decided that either Banach doesn't really believe what he's saying or too trapped in his own mind to realize that his ideology may only apply to himself.
This is why I find it hard to agree with Banach. Many points of his arguement make sense to me and I believe that he is on to something is is partially correct. However, his main point that we can understand each other or feel what others feel is simply incorrect. Again, if this is so then how does he know so much about what we feel and think or how we see things?
I think I've pointed out the biggest flaws of Banach's argument, now i would like to attempt to answer the question of our freedom and what freedom is.
There are two different types of freedom. Mental freedom and physical freedom. Mental freedom is something we all have that under no circumstance can be taken from us. We will always be allowed to believe what we want and in our minds we can picture whatever we wish. Our imagination and the thoughts inside our heads are limitless. I am allowed to think what i want "I have control over the content of my TV screen" says Banach reffering to his "mental TV screen." This is true nobody could ever enforce a law telling us what to believe in our own minds.
Physical freedom is a completely different story. This is limited. Not only do people have physical limits that do not allow them to fly, or morph in to other things but we also have limitations on things that are physically possible. Maybe I'm being confusing, but I'll try and explain. There are things that are physically possible that people are able to do but there are rules and laws restricitng us from doing these things or punishing us for these things. This many times is a good thing, it keeps people from harming other or doing things that are dangerous to others but it also restricts are freedom because you are not free to do these things. A very simple example is murder, you are not ALLOWED to kill someone else because you want to or for any reason, if you do this and get caught you will be punished. This is a good thing but it's also a restriction of freedom.
So when Banach says we have "absolute freedom" he's wrong. The word absolute implies that we have freedom in every sense of the word. Not true.
I think many people are confused by Banach's lecture and therefore simply agree. This is very understandable since many of his ideas make sense and are logical. I think looking deeper in to his argument you find that his ideas and theories are flawed.
Banach has some good ideas but overall I think his lecture says humans aren't smart enough or something enough to do something except for when it's in their own head but at the same time he doesn't apply the rule to himself. It just doesn't match. I think humans are capable of much more then Banach gives them credit for.
Tuesday, September 22, 2009
1st comments
Gavin,
This post basically summed up most of my thoughts. I agree with you 100 percent, I also believe humans do have the capacity to feel what others feel. Looking at this literally no one can ACTUALLY feel what someone else feels. However, I do think that people can feel the same things, im confusing myself here, I don't know if I'm making any sense but basically what I'm trying to say is that you can feel the same feelings as others.
People have so much in common and go through so many of the same things that I think it's inevitable that people will feel the same emotions as others. Now maybe it is your own emotion being revisited by someone else who is having that same emotion, but it is still the SAME emotion. I hope that makes sense.
Anyway I think the mentality that we are all alone is not a good one, I think it does more harm then good. Saying that we are all alone is saying that we can not relate or connect or come together as one, or it at least gives people the thought that it's not possible to come together with others. This si a twisted world we live in and with out a sense of unity and a group of people coming together things don't change. All change that has benefited the majority of people in the U.S has been caused by a large amount of people coming together and fighting for the same cause all having the same feelings or at least very similar feelings over the same thing. People are able to understand the ideology and feelings of other otherwise there would be no unity and I think we can agree that people do unite as it has happened in the past and is happening currently whether it be on a mass level or it be a smaller group of people, people do unite. Anyway, I feel like I'm repeating myself so I leave it at that hopefully I wasn't to confusing and it kind of made sense. Great post by the way. I look forward to more.
Arden,
That post was really good, especially the last paragraph. To me though the most interesting part of the post was when you ask if being individuals and only being able to truly understand ourselves makes us alone. I think that if you completely believe Banach's idea of individualism it does.
Banach's main point through most of the first part of the lecture is that we can really understand other only us and that we are all "stuck on our only islands of subjectivity." Now, this is true in many cases but I also believe that people can understand each other and have many of the same feelings. It is true that no two people are mentally identical but there are many things many people can share in common. Many times people go through the same expiriences and can relate and understand each other. I think that Banach is saying that we are alone and I think that is a potentially dangerous idea.
The idea that we are all alone and cannot connect and understand others is basically saying we can not come together and unite and I think that unity is what brings change when things go wrong. People do unite because of having the same issues and feeling the same way about certain things(not everyone feels the same way but many times some people do).
Anyway, those are just some of my thoughts of that idea. you had a really good post though and I look forward to reading future posts.
This post basically summed up most of my thoughts. I agree with you 100 percent, I also believe humans do have the capacity to feel what others feel. Looking at this literally no one can ACTUALLY feel what someone else feels. However, I do think that people can feel the same things, im confusing myself here, I don't know if I'm making any sense but basically what I'm trying to say is that you can feel the same feelings as others.
People have so much in common and go through so many of the same things that I think it's inevitable that people will feel the same emotions as others. Now maybe it is your own emotion being revisited by someone else who is having that same emotion, but it is still the SAME emotion. I hope that makes sense.
Anyway I think the mentality that we are all alone is not a good one, I think it does more harm then good. Saying that we are all alone is saying that we can not relate or connect or come together as one, or it at least gives people the thought that it's not possible to come together with others. This si a twisted world we live in and with out a sense of unity and a group of people coming together things don't change. All change that has benefited the majority of people in the U.S has been caused by a large amount of people coming together and fighting for the same cause all having the same feelings or at least very similar feelings over the same thing. People are able to understand the ideology and feelings of other otherwise there would be no unity and I think we can agree that people do unite as it has happened in the past and is happening currently whether it be on a mass level or it be a smaller group of people, people do unite. Anyway, I feel like I'm repeating myself so I leave it at that hopefully I wasn't to confusing and it kind of made sense. Great post by the way. I look forward to more.
Arden,
That post was really good, especially the last paragraph. To me though the most interesting part of the post was when you ask if being individuals and only being able to truly understand ourselves makes us alone. I think that if you completely believe Banach's idea of individualism it does.
Banach's main point through most of the first part of the lecture is that we can really understand other only us and that we are all "stuck on our only islands of subjectivity." Now, this is true in many cases but I also believe that people can understand each other and have many of the same feelings. It is true that no two people are mentally identical but there are many things many people can share in common. Many times people go through the same expiriences and can relate and understand each other. I think that Banach is saying that we are alone and I think that is a potentially dangerous idea.
The idea that we are all alone and cannot connect and understand others is basically saying we can not come together and unite and I think that unity is what brings change when things go wrong. People do unite because of having the same issues and feeling the same way about certain things(not everyone feels the same way but many times some people do).
Anyway, those are just some of my thoughts of that idea. you had a really good post though and I look forward to reading future posts.
Wednesday, September 16, 2009
Hw #1
When Banach says that we are all absolute idividuals he is saying that we all understand things in different ways and its impossible to feel what someone else is feeling or understand them. He is saying that we are all stuck in our own little world and we can not truly relate to others. I disagree,, i think people can relate. It is true that everyone is different and unique but people deal with many of the same or at least similar situations. People go through and feel many feelings that are the same. This is a topic that can never really be proved but from personal expirience I can say that people can relate and understand eachother because i have done it before. When people say things and you know exactly what they mean while others don't I think thats an example of some people relating and understanding eachother. Another example is music, music is a form of self expression. Music that is full of feeling and personal expirience gives people a chance to connect to very personal expiriences that the artist goes though and some people who feel the same things the artist do feel like they know exactly what the artist means. That feeling of connection is something that many people feel and i thin that is a feeling of understanding and connection. So when banach says "Each of us is trapped within our own mind, unable to feel anything but our own feelings and expiriences." I believe he is wrong because people connect and understand eachother constantly and that is why some people are able to create groups and become tight friends.
However, I believe that in many cases people do not understand others, but this is not because we are not able to. I think many times the case is that people try to fit in and be something or someonne they are not, in this case i do believe it is impossible to understand someone else. When you are not truly yourself your lying and decieveing everyone around you and many times your lying to yourself. When someone really expresses who they are and is themselves people can connect becuse it is a true and real feelings tht is shared amongst many and not something that is copied from someone else. When you are yourself and share your own true feelings others who have been through similar situations as you or simply feel the same as you do can connect and its a real feeling of understanding and connection of real feelings.
However, I believe that in many cases people do not understand others, but this is not because we are not able to. I think many times the case is that people try to fit in and be something or someonne they are not, in this case i do believe it is impossible to understand someone else. When you are not truly yourself your lying and decieveing everyone around you and many times your lying to yourself. When someone really expresses who they are and is themselves people can connect becuse it is a true and real feelings tht is shared amongst many and not something that is copied from someone else. When you are yourself and share your own true feelings others who have been through similar situations as you or simply feel the same as you do can connect and its a real feeling of understanding and connection of real feelings.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)