Sunday, October 4, 2009

Part III and IV

I believe human happiness cannot simply be defined in one sentence or by one person. What brings happiness varies from person to person. In many ways I agree with Banach when he says real happiness needs to found within oneself. However he then goes on to say this removes you more from external things so that external things don't affect your happiness. That I disagree with.

True happiness is something that you yourself have to find within yourself. However, your happiness can be altered by external things around you. If you are not affected by the things around you it is equivalent to accepting things for what they are and just dealing with them. This is not a good way to live. In class we spoke about that story of the guy who had to push the rock up the hill for all of eternity. People were saying you have to find the happiness or good side of everything. So this is like finding happiness and not letting anything affect you no matter how bad the situation is, having to push a rock up a hill for eternity is pretty bad. I think this is saying deal with what you have accept it and find the good side of it. Bullshit. If your poor are you supposed to be happy and find the good side of things or work for better things. If your homeless should you accept it and try to find a good side to it or should you go out and try to change things and get a house and put yourself in a better situation. This applies to every bad situation, should we just accept the financial issues that we all have to deal with today, or at least most of us, or should you go out and make some changes do something about it. I don't know about Banach or anybody else, but I would much rather work towards changing the things around me that are hurting me or keeping me from happiness instead of just accepting it and living with it.

Don't get me wrong, you should go around being mad all the time because of all the problems you have. You should have some kind of happiness but you should not just sit back and accept all the wrong doing that goes on in your life. Maybe I am misinterpreting what Banach is saying but I disagree when he says your happiness should not be affected by external sources.

As for the end of Banach's lecture where he wraps everything up, he contradicts himself EVEN MORE, I didn't really think that was possible. He says to really have absolute freedom we must wish freedom for all human beings but yet we are stuck in our island of subjectivity and we cannot relate and all of this BS about how we are all alone but yet to be truly free we need to have some sense of community. In the last paragraph Banach says "Existentialism attempts to find happiness, value, and meaning in a modern world characterized by isolation, inauthenticity, and absurdity." Ok so this guy is trying to say he is trying to find happiness in a world "characterized by isolation" yet throughout his whole lecture he talks about how we are alone and we are "stuck on our island of subjectivity" that seems very much like isolation too me.

I disagree with a lot of what Banach says because he contradicts himself so much and because I just disagree with him a lot. However I do think he made some valid points and he does bring up many interesting ideas throughout his lecture.

1 comment:

  1. OMAR,
    once again great blog post. I always enjoy reading your blog. and it always leaves me thinking.

    I really like how here you included more so you ideas. as well as summarizing what Banach had to say. It explains how you fit into all of this chaos. And getting both point of veiws was very interesting.

    you have some great ideas that would work well into writing your manifesto. You make a strong point when you say, "I believe human happiness cannot simply be defined in one sentence or by one person." by explaining even more in depth is great.

    ReplyDelete